欧博Ways to Hedge Against a Downturn _欧博ABG-会员注册-官网网址

Portfolio Management

Using S&P 500 Put Options to Hedge a Downturn

August 6, 2025 • Nathan Peterson • Advanced

Using S&P 500 put options for temporary downside portfolio protection when concerns over an event-driven sell-off are elevated.

Long-term portfolios are designed to be just that: long term. Selling a position as a reaction to market pullbacks may seem like a good idea, but it may lead to missed opportunities from improper market timing and losses from capital gains taxation.

There's a different option—literally. Buying protective puts on the S&P 500® index (SPX) is just one way investors can try to protect their portfolios against expected market downturns. These index options are cash-settled, highly liquid, and cover a broad swath of the U.S. stock market.

The downside is that put options contracts carry a premium. The more volatile the market, the higher the premium. In many circumstances, though, investors will find the degree of protection to be worth the money.

It's important to understand that portfolio hedging is an advanced topic, so investors considering this strategy should have experience using options and be familiar with the risks and the potential benefits before implementing this strategy. Investors still learning about options can find more introductory content at schwab.com/learn.

How to value a hedge

Investors pay a premium to set up a protective put position. The size of the position depends on how much of the portfolio they want to hedge. Hedging all of it is a lot more expensive than hedging part of it. The hedge also needs to protect the portfolio effectively. A hedge using S&P 500 puts will be less effective against an international portfolio than a portfolio of U.S. large-cap stocks that would likely better mirror the S&P.

A portfolio hedge could be considered effective if the value of the hedged portfolio holds relatively steady in the face of dropping asset prices. When trying to hedge an equity portfolio against a market sell-off, the hedge would be effective if it appreciates in value, or offsets some or all of the drop in equity prices. For example, if a trader strongly believes the stock market has the potential to fall 5% to 8% over the next three months, an effective hedging strategy that costs less than 5% of their total portfolio's value may be worth considering.

Example: Putting a portfolio hedge to work

Let's say a trader holds an equity portfolio worth $1 million that's highly correlated with the SPX and they're concerned the index may sell off substantially over the next three months. The trader is willing to spend approximately 2% of the total portfolio value—or $20,000—to hedge the portfolio over that time.

Assume the SPX is at 6,000 and the Cboe Volatility Index® (VIX)—the average 30-day implied volatility based on a basket of short-term SPX options—is at roughly 17. For this example, the trader is using out-of-the-money (OTM) options to obtain temporary downside protection in the event of a sell-off. The cost of an OTM SPX put option at the 5,710-strike is $10,000.

With the $20,000 they've allocated for hedging, the trader could potentially buy two OTM SPX 5,710-strike put options for a total of $20,000: $100 (ask) x 2 (# of contracts) x 100 (options multiplier) = $20,000 (excluding transaction costs).

The table below shows how hedging would affect the trader's portfolio value upon the expiration of the three-month SPX put options.

Portfolio value at expiration of three-month SPX put options

SPX percentage changeSPX valueCost of 2 SPX 5,710 putsValue at expiration of 2 SPX 5,710 puts Portfolio value (no hedge)Portfolio value with SPX putsHedged portfolio percentage changeUnhedged portfolio percentage change
+5% 6,300 $20,000 $0 $1,050,000 $1,030,00 +3% +5%
0% 6,000 $20,000 $0 $1,000,000 $980,000 -2% 0%
-5% 5,700 $20,000 $2,000 $950,000 $932,000 -6.8% -5%
-10% 5,400 $20,000 $62,000 $900,000 $942,000 -5.8% -10%
-15% 5,100 $20,000 $122,000 $850,000 $952,000 -4.8% -15%
-20% 4,800 $20,000 $182,000 $800,000 $962,000 -3.8% -20%

Source: Schwab Center for Financial Research

As seen above, the hedged portfolio maintained much of its value during the various SPX sell-off scenarios, but it underperformed the unhedged portfolio in the +5%, 0%, and –5% scenarios due to the cost of the protection strategy. Some investors will appreciate having the hedge in place, despite the cost.

Additional considerations

Bottom line

The hedging strategy presented above provides a way to hedge an entire portfolio, but is the cost worth the benefit? Some investors may take comfort in knowing that the "worst-case scenario" for a hedged portfolio is being down 6.8% for the next three months. Others may want more coverage and be willing to pay for protection against smaller declines. Still, others may feel that the cost is too high or establishing a short-term hedge is equivalent to timing the market and, therefore, may elect to focus on the long term.

The cost of a protective index put option is higher the more likely it is that it will be needed. Investors need to assess their own risk tolerance and comfort with the market outlook before buying protection against a downturn.

Looking for professional investment advice?

See how Schwab can help

搜索

热门标签:

欧博Ways to Hedge Against a Downturn